The Working State Needs Front Doors Young People Trust
A guarantee needs a door
When we opened the first Citizen Hub in St Neots, we called it a community-led alternative to the job centre.
We had no funding. We had a space, some brilliant people and a hunch that people will walk into a place they trust long before they walk into one that judges them.
Today Alan Milburn published his final report on young people and work. Nearly one million young people are not in education, employment or training. That's one in eight. Six in ten of them have never had a job.
My team and I have read all 278 pages, so you don't have to. Below are the headlines, then how I see this playing out for anyone running a community space, a college, an employment programme or a fund.
One working assumption. I expect most of this to be adopted largely as written. So this isn't about whether it happens. It's about what it looks like on the ground if it does, based on what we know today.
I'm reading it through one lens remember, social infrastructure. The places, people and relationships that sit between a young person and the system. That's where this report will succeed or fail.
The headlines in two minutes
The ambition is "NEET Zero": a NEET rate of around 5% by 2036. The Review's own modelling gets to 6.8%, against 13.4% if nothing changes. Seven big moves get it there.
- Two guarantees, written into law. The Opportunity Guarantee is a route into a job, an apprenticeship, a college place, a work placement, civic service or starting a business. The Support Guarantee is the health, employment and practical help needed to take it. Both cover every 18 to 24 year-old who is NEET, whether or not they claim benefits.
- A Youth Opportunity Service in every place by 2029. One front door for young people and employers. A named adviser within 14 days, one participation plan within four weeks, something real underway within four months. If nothing else has worked after 12 months, a paid six-month job.
- Mayors own the 16 to 24 system. Each strategic authority writes one Area Youth Participation Plan with councils, the NHS, colleges, employers, the voluntary sector and young people.
- Multi-year deals with Whitehall. Money, powers and funding for at least three years. The first wave would test places keeping a share of the savings when NEET rates fall.
- A new benefits system for under-25s. A single Youth Allowance, no Work Capability Assessment, a duty to engage and sanctions as a rare backstop.
- A new deal with employers. £3,000 for hiring a young person who has been NEET for six months, more for small firms and bigger barriers, and an employer movement called First Chance.
- The money. £500m in 2027/28 from reprioritised budgets, rising to about £5.8bn a year by 2036/37. That's offset by £3.6bn of welfare savings and £2.4bn more in tax and lower benefit payments.
The Youth Opportunity Service works through 6 ways in and 6 routes out. Whichever door a young person uses, they reach the same service, one adviser within 14 days and one plan within 4 weeks. If nothing else has worked after 12 months, the State secures a paid six-month job.
How I see it playing out
If the government says yes, the Review's own timetable is fast. The next 12 months matter more than the next ten years.
Proposed timetable - first 100 days to the early 2030s
First 100 days - Government confirms the ambition, the entitlements and who is accountable.
2027 - £500m deployed. Every area writes its plan and starts building its service. First Chance launches The guarantees and benefit changes go to Parliament.
2028 - Established mayoral areas have their agreements and a working service. Apprenticeship and college reforms widen access to training.
2029 - Every area has a Youth Opportunity Service, with health support built in. New benefits for under-25s start once a local service is in place.
Early 2030s - A full statutory system in every place in England. The NEET rate falling, and no 16 or 17-year-old NEET.
These dates are the Review's proposals, not yet government commitments.
Here's what I think that means on the ground.
- The room fills up in 2027. Area Youth Participation Plans get written next year. Organisations in that room will shape the service. Organisations outside it will be told what it is. Lets make sure the right experience is supporting that across the UK.
- Employment support goes local. From 2027/28, youth employment support starts moving inside the Youth Opportunity Service, commissioned by mayors. National contracts will need local roots.
- The hidden young people are the real test. 314,000 young people who are NEET aren't in the benefits system at all. No letter from DWP will find them. A trusted local place might.
- We're near the front of the queue. Cambridgeshire and Peterborough has just been designated an Established Mayoral Strategic Authority. Those are the areas first in line for full Participation Agreements from what I understand. Let's make it happen Paul Bristow, great opportunity to be the trailblazers of the UK.
- By 2029 the question changes. It won't be whether every area has a front door. It will bewhether young people choose to walk through it.
What he gets right
There's one sentence I'll be quoting for years: "One front door does not mean one building."
The Review wants the new service to work "through places and organisations young people already know and trust". Mayors could commission it from a charity, a college, a social enterprise, a community organisation or a football club foundation. That's a long way from another government office with a new logo.
In The Hague, Milburn found a youth service built on a simple rule: "relationship goes first, system goes second". Frontline staff could sort out travel, work clothes or a laptop on the spot, rather than lose the opportunity while a form went round. Anyone who has run a community space knows that's where the job is won or lost.
He's honest about what's broken. "Trusted staff and relationships disappear with the funding cycle," he writes, and he calls for funding of at least three years. Every charity leader reading that will nod.
And he's right about trust. The Review asked NEET young people who they believed could find solutions. 45% said young people with lived experience. Charities and youth organisations got 11%. Government got 5%.
That 11% should humble our sector as much as the 5% humbles government. Being a charity doesn't make you trusted. Being there, week after week, does. Infrastructure that is community led is a complete hack to fast tracking trust, lean in to this please and no, you can't just say it was done with your community it has to be them leading the change.
The missing words: social infrastructure
Milburn never uses the phrase social infrastructure. But he describes it on almost every page.
He writes that youth programmes come and go "while the permanent infrastructure connecting young people, employers and places remains weak". He says too much of the system only works because one adult goes beyond their job. A teacher stays involved. A youth worker refuses to give up. The young person with a relentless advocate gets pulled back. The one without can disappear.
That's social infrastructure. It's the difference between a young person who gets found and one who doesn't.
His own numbers make the case. 81% of school work placements are arranged by the student or their family. 78% of school staff say family connections are the main reason some pupils benefit more than others. Only 31% of young people feel confident they have networks that could help them. One young person put it bluntly: "If you have zero links, you cannot get a job in this day and age."
Here's my challenge. Belonging gets three passing mentions in 278 pages. The report counts plans, starts and sustained participation. None of its proposed measures count connection.
That's our "yes, and". Through the 3% Club in the East of England, we're proposing a Community Guarantee to sit alongside the Opportunity Guarantee. Every young person who becomes NEET is referred within a week to a trusted local community hub or youth group. Within six months, they have ten people who know their name and will vouch for them.
Then count it. Alongside job starts, count the adults outside their family each young person can turn to. Call it the ten-people test. It's the case Sam Squire and I made to the Minister for Employment yesterday.
If ten people know your name, they will vouch for you. A working state should measure that.
What we've learned on the high street
In June, young people from Inspire 2 Ignite sat down at Citizen Hub St Neots with local business leaders and researchers contributing to this report. They didn't hold back.
They talked about applications that never got a reply. Jobs advertised when someone inside had already been lined up. Not being able to afford work clothes or the bus. One line stayed with everyone in the room: "We are more than our grades."
Milburn heard almost exactly the same. 53% of NEET young people who want to work say lack of experience is their biggest barrier. He asks employers to end the "wall of silence" for rejected applicants.
Here's what a hub does that a programme can't. An employment adviser from Reed in Partnership works out of our St Neots hub. The same room hosts a health charity one week and a job club the next. People come in for one thing and find another. Health, social, skills and employment are our four pillars. Belonging is what holds them up.
Our newest hub, The BRDG in Peterborough, is anchored by Inspire Education Group. A college provides the building and the people. We bring the model, the playbook and the community.
We're not the only proof. Centre 33's open-access drop-ins in Cambridgeshire and Peterborough are a case study in the Review. In 2025, 15% of young people using the drop-ins were NEET, against 2% of those who came through statutory referral. The open door finds the young people the system misses.
So I'm retiring a phrase. Citizen Hub was never really an alternative to the job centre. It isn't an alternative to the State. It's the front door to it and we would be proud to continue that evolution to bridge trust with our communities, both from a civic participation perspective and the social and economic outcomes for residents.
What it means for the rest of us
- Community and youth organisations. You're written into the design as front doors, delivery partners and even operators. But the bar goes up, common standards, a named adviser, shared data and safeguarding. Success will be measured as young people staying in work or learning, not as starts. Get ready now.
- Employment support providers. Youth employment support moves inside the local service from 2027/28. The providers who do well will be partnered with places young people already trust, please do not underestimate or undervalue these organisations, they are essential to success in these plans.
- Colleges. A new premium for re-engaging NEET 16 and 17 year-olds, funding that rewards destinations, and 150,000 more 18 to 24 year-olds in further education. Colleges can be both the front door and the landlord, lets hope the government follows it up with funding that they can meet that need, then for the colleges, come and help rebuild the high street to rebuild trust with our young people.
- The NHS. Integrated Care Boards get a duty to fund health support for the local service. Social prescribing becomes a core service, linking young people to activities and groups that build "wellbeing, confidence, belonging and participation". That's a commissioning route for community spaces.
- Funders. The statutory system won't be fully in place until 2029. The next three years are the bridge. Fund the front door, not just the project and fund it for three years. The Review names impact investment and philanthropy as partners to public money.
- Employers. Hiring a young person who has been NEET for six months would bring a £3,000 payment. A small firm taking on someone facing bigger barriers could get up to £7,000. One route in through the local service and three First Chance asks for first jobs, apprenticeships and work experience. Then, please just reply to every applicant, find a way to at least acknowledge it.
- High streets. The Review wants support in "everyday locations like schools, workplaces and high streets" and a physical service "within a reasonable travel time from home" for every young person. The empty units are already there, the high street is so underpriced right now, lets make this a revolution to build the next generation of high street on belonging, impact, learning and experiences!
Where it could go wrong
"Haven't we been here before?" Yes and the review says so itself. The Youth Training Scheme, the New Deal, the Future Jobs Fund, Kickstart. All came and went. This time the difference is meant to be the law and multi-year money. Neither exists yet and the first £500m is reprioritised, not new.
A tidy system can squeeze out the trusted one. Each Area Youth Participation Plan will decide "which current activities and programmes should stop". Fair enough in principle. But a neat system run on common standards can push out the small organisations young people actually walk into. The Review says young people "should not lose trusted relationships because services are being reorganised". We should hold everyone account to that line.
Order matters on welfare. The loudest argument today will be about benefits. For under-25s, the Review proposes ending the Work Capability Assessment and replacing PIP, with sanctions as a last resort. It admits some young people could get less at the start of a claim. I'm not a welfare expert and I won't pretend to be. But the Review's own rule is that the guarantees come before any benefit changes. From where I sit, that order isn't negotiable for this to be effective.
Data only works if trust survives. Joining up data to find young people earlier is right. It's only right if the review's legal firewall holds, so that information gathered to help a young person is never reused for benefit sanctions or unrelated policing. Let's make data collection a community opportunity and use it to empower innovation in social impact services and support.
What I'm asking for
To government and mayors:
- Commission front doors from places young people already trust, not rebadged offices. Work directly with the impact sector to empower them to drive these plans with your officers.
- Fund them for three years from day one, starting with the mobilisation money the Review proposes. Fund the building and the belonging, not just the caseload.
- Count connection, not just starts. Add the ten-people test to the participation measures.
- Put the guarantees in place before any benefit changes.
To everyone in the sector reading this:
- Get into your Area Youth Participation Plan now. Bring young people in as partners, not consultees.
- Stop competing for the same young people. Build local partnerships before a commissioner asks you to, this is the way we all make a generational impact that is needed in this moment!
- Reply to every young person who applies, asks or walks in. It costs nothing and it's the first thing they told us was missing.
Back to the door
Milburn tells the story of a young woman who said young people aren't "not in education, employment or training". They're "desperate for education, employment and training".
They're not short of ambition. They're short of a door they trust and people behind it who know their name.
A guarantee is only as good as the door you walk through to claim it.
Let's build the doors shall we?!

